Item Coversheet

CITY OF OAKLAND PARK, FLORIDA
CITY COMMISSION AGENDA ITEM REPORT


A
GENDA ITEM NO. 4

MEETING DATE: 4/6/2022
PREPARED BY: 

Alex Dambach, AICP

Planning Supervisor

 

Lauren Pruss, AICP

Assistant Director of Community and Economic Development

 

Peter Schwarz, AICP

Director of Community and Economic Development

DEPARTMENT HEAD APPROVAL:  ECD - Planning
SUBJECT:

Case #CD21-09T “Electric Vehicle Charging” A public hearing to consider an ordinance to amend the City of Oakland Park Code of Ordinances, Chapter 24, Land Development Code to require electric vehicle charging infrastructure for all newly constructed residential buildings and charging stations at newly constructed multi-family and mixed-use residential projects.

1.BACKGROUND/HISTORY
    
 

Legislative History: The City Commission approved this item on first reading at the May 5, 2021 meeting by a vote of 5-0. The Commission instructed staff to update the proposed ordinance prior to second reading.

 

During first reading (minutes attached), the Commission discussed the item and directed staff to consider the following updates to the ordinance:

 

1. Increase the required amount of parking spaces with charging stations in new multi-family and mixed use residential developments from five percent to ten percent.

 

2.  Address residential developments that would not have garages or indoor areas for charging stations.

 

3.  Accommodate residential developments with limited parking availability.

 

4.  Discussion with building industry and Electrical permit staff for guidance.

 

5.  Incentives for installation.

 

6.  Consider timeline for implementation.

 

Issue StatementIn order to accommodate the increasing utilization of electric vehicles, regulations requiring electric vehicle charging infrastructure for newly constructed residential properties are proposed to benefit the environment and the City of Oakland Park.

  

Recommended Action:  The City Commission conduct a public hearing and thereafter adopt the Ordinance on Second Reading to require electric vehicle charging infrastructure at new single-family, two-family and townhouse residential and electric vehicle charging infrastructure and charging stations at new multi-family and mixed-use residential projects.

 

BackgroundOn March 3, 2021, The City Commission reached consensus directing staff to bring forward a revision to Chapter 24, Land Development Code to include a building code requirement for 220 electrical outlets in new construction in the garage or carport for electric vehicles. 

 

Since that meeting, staff has consulted with, and received further information from the Building and Engineering Department's Electrical Subcode Official and from construction companies currently building in Oakland Park.

 

Level 1 charging uses typical residential 120 volt, 15 amp infrastructure, which facilitates 'slow charging,' providing 3-5 miles of driving distance per hour of charge. Building codes already require a standard outlet receptacle in all residential garages.

 

Level 2 charging uses a minimum of 208 volts (typically 240 volts) and a minimum of 30 amps to provide 12 to 80 miles of driving distance per hour of charge. This level of infrastructure is similar to that required for large household appliances such as electric stoves, central air conditioning units, clothes dryers, and water heaters. This is the requirement for residential units as proposed with this ordinance.


Level 3 charging Typically uses 480 volts and 100 amps or more to provide 180 or more miles of driving distance per hour of charge. This level of infrastructure requires specialized infrastructure and equipment. Often these are operated as commercial enterprises but may also operate at high volume locations. 

 

Planning and Zoning Board: At the Planning and Zoning Board’s meeting of April 12, 2021, the proposed zoning text amendment was presented at a public hearing. The Planning and Zoning Board took an action by a vote of 4-0 to recommend approval of the Ordinance, with the added recommendation that City staff consider an additional text amendment in the future requiring electric vehicle charging stations at commercial business and city-owned facilities as well at any new development. The approved minutes from this meeting are attached.

2.CURRENT ACTIVITY
    
 

The revised ordinance requires 10 percent of parking spaces in new multi-family and mixed-use residential developments to have Level 2 electric vehicle charging stations. However, as an incentive, it permits this percentage to lower to 5 percent if the developer provides Level 3 charging.

 

The ordinance further adds the following requirements:

 

  • Receptacles and charging stations, if required, shall be located indoors if garage parking is provided, but if there is only outdoor parking, the receptacle or charging station shall be positioned at the most convenient, but secure, location to access the parking space.
  • The receptacle shall be installed in a location that is the least visible possible from any public right-of-way. There are also size limits for outdoor signage to avoid a visual impact on the surrounding streets.
  • Accommodates adjustments that can be approved by the Development Review Committee if a development has extenuating circumstances.

 

The following summarizes the proposed text amendments, with updates based on Commission directives, the to the City of Oakland Park Land Development Code: 

 

1. New single-family, two-family and townhouse residential: shall provide all necessary infrastructure for one (1) Level 2 electric vehicle station per residential unit at the time of construction. Required infrastructure shall include the electric wiring, conduit, receptacle, and circuit breakers necessary to readily accommodate future installation of the charging station by a user. Wiring, conduit, and receptible shall be installed up to the point where the charging station will be located and shall be indoors if garage parking exists or shall be at the most convenient but least visible location if the parking spaces are outdoors. 

 

2. New multi-family and mixed-use residential: (excluding two-family and townhouse residential) shall install electric vehicle charging infrastructure and Level 2 charging station(s) within the project at the rate of ten (10) percent of the total number of required residential parking spaces as required or approved by the Development Review Committee, which may adjust the requirement based on extenuating circumstances. If ten (10) percent calculates to less than one, at least one electric vehicle charging station shall be installed. As an incentive for a developer to provide Level 3 charging, the required number of charging stations would be reduced to five (5) percent if these higher speed chargers are provided.

 

3. Additional requirements: provisions for signage, defining the calculation of the number of parking spaces required to comply with this ordinance, weather protection, and implementation information.  This ordinance would not take effect until June 30, 2022.

3.FINANCIAL IMPACT
    
 Not Applicable.
4.RECOMMENDATION
    
 The City Commission conduct a public hearing and thereafter adopt the Ordinance to require electric vehicle charging infrastructure at new single-family, two-family and townhouse residential and electric vehicle charging infrastructure and charging stations at new multi-family and mixed-use residential projects.
ATTACHMENTS:
Description
Ordinance
Guidance from Electrical Sub-Code Official
EV Charging 101
Car and Driver Magazine Article
Neocharge Blog on Electric Vehicle Charging
Planning and Zoning Board Meeting Minutes - April 12, 2021
City Commission Meeting Minutes - May 5, 2021